Muslim scholar argues that 653 hadiths in Sahih Bukhari and Sahih Muslim are false January 4, 2009 1:05 pmBy Jamal al-Banna, brother of Muslim Brotherhood founder Hassan al-Banna I just heard about this controversy while watching Arabic satellite. So I did a bit of googling and found the following 2 week-old report. While this story has gotten virtually no attention here in the West, it is apparently causing problems in the Islamic world, especially Egypt, where it originates. Muslims have traditionally believed that the hadiths of Bukhari and Muslim — both of which are prefixed with that all-important Arabic word, Sahih, that is, “verified” or “authenticated” — are true, indeed, second in authority only to the Koran. Simultaneously, there are a number of outrageous hadiths in these two collections — such as (breastfeeding the adult) — which, at least some Muslims, would prefer if they were stricken out of the hadith corpus. The problem, of course, is if Muslim scholars cast doubt on a single hadith in Bukhari and Muslim, the collections in their entirety become suspect.

The Muslim Issa is only a prophet. But they fail to see that the. A courageous Muslim man says what many of us would like to! Where did he come from? Is he the God of the Bible? Kishore Kumar Songs Free Download Kishore Kumar Collection Mp3 here. Any wise enemy is better than an ignorant friend. Goldfinger Radio Drama Format. The Cleansing Of Bukhari And Muslim From Useless Hadiths Pdf To Word. A very informative.

And without these two otherwise canonical hadith collections, Sunni Islam — which relies more on the hadith than even the Koran when it comes to regulating life — becomes unintelligible; sharia law falls apart. Another one of Islam’s “catch-22″ situations. “Jamal al-Banna’s new book: critique of Bukhari and Muslim,” by John Stringer for, December 18. Yes, so first grow up then comment on something which is respected by billion Muslims. Thank you.It s respected for u?I think the age is not important! I read it and I found out my prophet (I refuge to Allah) is sexy and crazy man base on what read on those.I know he is not so,coz this I found out that these books r the worst!I m 16 but I have brain and can think and understand. I even see myself the caricatures which were drawn for prophet and found out that they r base on Sahih Bukhari!If this book is right,so those caricatures r right and they r not insulting!